Roth IRAs – A Viable Option for College Funding?

Lately, there has been much confusion regarding the benefits of using a Roth IRA to finance a college education on a tax-free basis. This is due to the complexity of rules on taking distributions/withdrawals from Roth IRAs. There are two kinds of money in a Roth IRA: contributions and earnings. Unlike a traditional IRA, contributions to a Roth are never tax-deductible.

Since taxes have already been paid taxes on the contributions, these can be withdrawn at any time, for any reason, without paying taxes, although they may be subject to the early 10% withdrawal penalty if they come out of a Roth within five tax years. Fortunately, that penalty is waived if the contributions are used for higher education expenses such as going to college.

The same can be done with non-deductible contributions made to traditional IRAs. But, the money earned by those contributions, such as capital gains, interest and dividends is untaxed money. Untaxed money cannot be taken out without paying income tax on it until the age of 59 1/2 or older. There are some exceptions to this rule, but unfortunately higher education is not one of them.

If the earnings are withdrawn from a Roth, they are taxed at ordinary earned income rates, not the more favorable capital gains rates. Don't even think about using Roth earnings for college. A person would be far better off with a taxable account. However, a person can use Roth contributions for college.

This option is viable only if the individual has some other type of retirement plan that is funded to satisfactorily.  Obviously, the individual’s future support should come first, and the individual’s children can work their way through college. Thus, as long as the Roth isn't all that stands between a person and a mediocre, poverty ridden retirement, then yes, the Roth has some potential for college funding.

Nobody will lend an individual money for a comfortable retirement, but a student can borrow money for college. The point of saving for college is to hopefully avoid the need for a student to borrow.

But bumps in the financial road do happen sometimes, and the bottom line is that if it comes down to an either/or situation, it's more important that there is a reasonable level of retirement savings more than large college savings fund.

As far as the tax advantages are concerned, a person might as well hide the money under a mattress. The individual is simply putting some money, on which taxes have already been paid, into the Roth for a while, then taking it back out and using it to pay for college.

No taxes are paid on that kind of withdrawal just like a person wouldn't pay taxes on withdrawals from a savings account, or money you stashed in a coffee can. The tax advantages of saving for college in a Roth is good. While a person will not get tax-free treatment on earnings saved in a Roth if used for college, the contributions can be withdrawn for college expenses without tax or penalty.

The obvious solution is to leave the earnings in the Roth for retirement and withdraw the principal to pay college bills. There is some flexibility in using a Roth IRA, but here are also yearly contribution limits for the Roth, with the annual limit for the Roth IRA increasing to $4,000 in 2005, a married couple will be able to save a full $8,000 per year in Roth IRAs.

Many families with kids aren't going to be able to save more than that anyway, and if they can, the Coverdell accounts are still available to save an extra $2,000 per child per year. The treatment of college funding is often confusing, it is sufficient to say that having college savings money held in a Roth IRA can simplify the treatment of financial aid and education tax credits.